STUDIUM AND PUNCTUM IN EVERDAY PHOTOGRAPHY


EVERYDAY PHOTOGRAPHY

To collect photograph is like to collect the world (Sontang Susan (2006)), Casual/Everyday photography is a term that was rather self-generated and not put forward by someone. Casual photography can be pursued by anyone who has a device to capture a photo, this process had begun rather ages ago when the first affordable 35 mm roll was invented to take still pictures.  The photo below portrays a casual picture, this photo was taken by me during a trip to New Zealand. 

 

The cute dog in this photo is lula and this photo 
was taken without any motive

PUNCTUM AND STUDIUM 

The distinction between Studium and punctum is “the order of liking, not loving” (Barthes 1981a:27). Puntum and stadium was proposed by a Roland Barthes a French literacy theorist, he put forward his idea in a book named 'Camera Lucida' which was published by Hill & Wang. The difference between puncture and stadium can be compared to the difference between interest and passion. Barthes in his book stated that studium is "Enthusiastic commitment" for a picture, the viewer of the photo enjoys the photo but not at a deeper level, the photo simply does not draw viewers towards it. Puncture is a sense of 'change', it tends to connect to the viewers at a deeper level. It unexpectedly intrigues the person that is viewing the picture, the photo does not rely on the interest of its viewer's because it is so strong that it tends to stand on its own. Movie Billboards and posters are an example of punctum in everyday life, movie producers use punctum to bring in a large audience and draw their attention.The basics of punctum and stadium is elaborately discussed in the video below. 




HOW DO YOU KNOW IF THE PHOTO IS PUNTCUM OR STUDIUM ? 

What makes this picture interesting? Why do i care? These questions are slowly answered by looking deeply into what interest you as a person and figuring out why with the help of punctum and stadium.I have an interest in art thus when i see a picture that is in the genre of art it automatically spikes an interest to me. When people look at a picture of their interest it is most likely that photo is a punctum to them but this is a false understanding. Photos which are punctum do not rely on the person interest, at one glance it should have the ability to pierce the viewer and. A punctum photo has its own persona and demands the attention of the viewer, while a studium is the opposite of that. Bathers called studium 'a kind of education (civility, politeness) that allow discovery of the operator'. Have you ever wondered why you are drawn to a newspaper ads that have items on sale ? This is technique used by sellers to draw your attention and thus creating a punctum ad.

Roland Bathers categorised puntcum into three factors -
1.    Unintentional nature
2.    Power of expansion 
3.    Temporality 

PUNCTUM EXAMPLE 








The picture above is called 'The vulture and the little girl', taken by Kevin Carter a South African photojournalist who was on a assignment to Sudan.The picture is of a heart-wrenching girl trying to make it to the UN camp for food supplies, As and when Kevin carter saw this girl a vulture flew behind the girl. Kevin waited a good amount for the vulture to get close to the girl so that he can take the perfect shot. This picture can have many interpretations but at one glance it portrays a strong message that spikes interest in out mind.
Roland Barthes found the below picture as an example of punctum, he said "This particular punctum arouses great sympathy in me , almost a kind of tenderness." 




STUDIUM EXAMPLE 



Roland Barthes idea of a studium is when " I glance though them, I do not recall them; no detail ever interrupts my reading: I am interested in them, I do not love them". The picture above is an example of a stadium picture. The picture portrays a giant tree in a field, this is an ideal example of a studium because even though a slight interest may rise while viewing the picture, it creates no impactful presence in front of the viewer. Examples of studium pictures in everyday life can be found on Instagram the general users of Instagram upload selfies and pictures of normal objects around them with exceptions to popular accounts. Selfies and other normal pictures do not spark much interest and can be categorized under studium.


USING THESE DUALITY IN EVERYDAY PHOTOGRAPHY

Century ago the technology to take pictures was not as advanced as today, Cameras were costly and poor quality while nowadays everybody has a device that can capture a picture with ease. Every individual has a unique way of taking pictures and a unique style of interest. As (Singh, R & Ladsaria, S, K) said "Photography is a structural grammar that deals with “trans-linguistic” fields of communication.". Youtubers today reel in millions of people into watching their videos by using pictures which are punctum, these videos serve the purpose as "Click bait". So why do people fall for click bait videos? Its because youtubers have started to use the technique of punctum to ignite interest in people.

So, the next time you come across a picture and analyze it to identify if it is a punctum or a studium ask the following questions to yourself 
1.    Does this picture make me interested?
1.    Do i want to ask questions about the picture (Example: backstory, explanation, etc.)
1.    How does this picture affect me?


REFRENCES

Barthes, R. (1993). Camera Lucida. London: Hill & Wang.

Rau, P. (2006). Beyond punctum and studium: Trauma and photography in Rachel Seiffert’s the dark room. Journal of European Studies, 36(3), 295.

Singh, R & Ladsaria, S. (2017). READING ‘STUDIUM’ AND ‘PUNCTUM’ IN STEVE MCCURRY AND RAGHU RAI’S PHOTOGRAPHY. Journal of the Humanities and Social Studies, 21(1), 33. http://dx.doi/10.3176/tr.2017.1.03

Sontag, S. (2001). On photography. New York: Picador USA: Farrar, Straus and Giroux, pp 3-24.

Sudane Famine” by Cliff is licensed under CC BY 2.0.

“James Van der Zee, Family Portrait (1926)” by Catherine Gander is licensed under C 

Tree” by Hilary Halliwell is licensed under CC BY 2.0.

“Lula” by Umang Snehi is licensed by Umang Snehi (me).





    



    

















Comments